We envision three types of CIRTL program outcomes: Associate, Practitioner, and Scholar. These three CIRTL outcomes recognize: first, the role of the CIRTL core ideas in effective teaching and learning; second, scholarly teaching that uses the CIRTL core ideas to demonstrably improve learning of students; and finally, scholarship that advances teaching and learning, and makes the results public. CIRTL program outcomes permit anyone to enter the CIRTL Network learning community from a wide variety of disciplines, needs, and past experiences, and to achieve success as a teacher at a wide variety of engagement.
ASSOCIATE
CIRTL Associate — Describe and Recognize Value
Learning Objectives
see Associate certification requirements
Process
TEACHING-AS-RESEARCH
- Describe how to access the literature and existing knowledge about teaching and learning issues, in a discipline or more broadly.
- Define and recognize the value of the Teaching-as-Research process, and how it can be used for ongoing enhancement of learning.
- Describe a “full-inquiry” cycle.
- Describe how the integration of Evidence-Based Teaching, Learning Communities and Learning-through-Diversity within Teaching-as-Research can be integrated to implement and advance effective teaching practices for diverse learners.
Content
EVIDENCE-BASED TEACHING
- Describe and recognize the value of realistic well-defined, achievable, measurable and student-centered learning goals.
- Describe several known high-impact, evidence-based effective instructional practices and materials and recognize their alignment with particular types of learning goals.
- Describe several assessment techniques and recognize their alignment with particular types of learning goals.
LEARNING COMMUNITIES
- Describe and recognize the value of learning communities, and how they impact student learning.
- Describe several techniques for creating a LC within a learning environment, including strategies that promote positive interdependence between learners so as to accomplish learning goals.
- Describe several techniques and issues of establishing LCs comprising a diverse group of learners.
- Recognize the value of and participate in local professionally-focused learning communities associated with teaching and learning.
LEARNING THROUGH DIVERSITY
- Describe the scope of diversity in learning environments, of both students and instructor.*
- Describe the impact of diversity on student learning, in particular how diversity can enhance learning, and how inequities can negatively impact learning if not addressed.
- Describe how an instructor’s beliefs and biases can influence student learning.
- Describe and recognize the value of drawing on diversity in the development of teaching plans (including content, teaching practices and assessments) to foster learning.
- Describe several learning-through-diversity (LtD) techniques and strategies.
* Including, but not limited to, educational background, race, gender, ability, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, and cognitive skill.
PRACTITIONER
CIRTL Practitioner — Develop and Implement
Learning Objectives
see Practitioner certification requirements
Process
TEACHING-AS-RESEARCH
- Develop and execute a Teaching-as-Research plan for a limited teaching and learning project*
- Find and critically consider the literature and existing knowledge associated with the teaching and learning project.
- Create realistic well-defined, achievable, measurable and student-centered learning goals for the teaching and learning project.
- Find or develop assessment (measurement) tool(s) that are aligned with the learning goals of the teaching and learning project.
- Develop a teaching plan (a hypothesis) to accomplish learning goals.
- Implement the teaching plan and collect some data regarding achievement of learning goals.
- Analyze the data and draw evidence-based conclusions about the impact on student learning.
- Complete a full-inquiry cycle for the teaching and learning project by using findings to suggest improvements to the above actions.
- Show the integration of Evidence-Based Teaching, Learning Communities and Learning-through-Diversity to accomplish learning goals.
* Often this will be a first TAR effort, and need not be extensive or intended for public presentation. Optimally the project will be a coherent, complete experience of the full-inquiry cycle, but opportunities and situations vary from campus-to-campus and student-to-student.
Content
EVIDENCE-BASED TEACHING
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of existing evidence-based knowledge concerning high-impact, evidence-based teaching practices.
- Integrate one or more evidence-based teaching strategies into a teaching plan so as to accomplish learning goals.
- Implement one or more evidence-based teaching strategies for students in a learning experience.
LEARNING COMMUNITIES
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of the knowledge concerning LCs and their impact on student learning.
- Integrate one or more LC strategies into a teaching plan so as to accomplish learning goals and learning-through-diversity.
- Implement one or more LC strategies for students in a learning experience.
- Contribute to local professionally-focused learning communities associated with teaching and learning.
LEARNING THROUGH DIVERSITY
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of diversity and its impact on accomplishing learning goals.
- Examine and describe own beliefs and biases, including how they may influence their students’ learning.
- Determine the diverse backgrounds among a group of students, and consider the opportunities and challenges of the findings on each student’s learning.
- Create a teaching plan that incorporates content and teaching practices responsive to the students’ backgrounds.
- Integrate one or more LtD techniques and strategies in a teaching plan so as to use students’ diversity to enhance the learning of all.
- Implement one or more LtD strategies in a teaching experience.
SCHOLAR
CIRTL Scholar — Advance and Disseminate
Learning Objectives
see Scholar certification requirements
CIRTL Scholars have added to community knowledge about teaching and learning. They have designed and implemented a Teaching-as-Research investigation, and defended the findings to CIRTL learning-community peers. The significance of CIRTL Scholar Teaching-as-Research work is established through presentation and/or publication of the findings to all-university, regional, national, or international audiences.
Goal 1: Develop evidence-based teaching knowledge
CIRTL participants learn instructional strategies supported by educational research to reach all learners through transparent, student-centered practices that foster belonging and enhance student learning and success. Participants explore when and how to apply relevant teaching and mentoring approaches, are equipped to articulate why they matter for learners, and identify ways that intentional reflection can improve their own teaching.
Goal 2: Connect with community to enhance teaching
CIRTL participants connect with future faculty peers, skilled educators, and established researchers in their own campus communities and through CIRTL’s international network of higher education institutions. Participants deepen their own knowledge of student-centered pedagogical principles as they progress through their academic careers by working together to explore, discuss, practice, reflect, and iterate around teaching and mentoring skills and experiences. This sustained engagement helps participants see how connecting with a community of educators from a variety of disciplines, backgrounds, and academic experiences can foster continued growth as an instructor.
Goal 3: Cultivate teaching skills through reflective improvement
CIRTL participants apply their teaching and learning knowledge through guided practice of evidence-based skills and approaches. Participants are encouraged to identify questions they have about teaching and learning, conceive of data-driven ways to examine those questions in real learning environments, and reflect on how lessons learned from that exploration can improve their teaching for the benefit of all learners. Participants integrate different ways of knowing from their disciplines and lived experiences to advance their knowledge of teaching and learning. At the same time, they also develop the practice of reflective, evidence-based, iterative improvement – a practice that they can return to throughout their careers.
Goal 4: Prepare for an impactful career
CIRTL participants experience the dynamic nature of teaching and learning through the breadth of universities represented in the CIRTL Network. Participants have the opportunity to identify professional interests and career pathways that match those interests; develop materials that articulate their values and strengths as educators, such as teaching philosophy and mentoring statements; and understand potential opportunities for impact as they advance professionally.