We envision three types of CIRTL program outcomes: Associate, Practitioner, and Scholar. These three CIRTL outcomes recognize: first, the role of the CIRTL core ideas in effective teaching and learning; second, scholarly teaching that uses the CIRTL core ideas to demonstrably improve learning of students; and finally, scholarship that advances teaching and learning, and makes the results public. CIRTL program outcomes permit anyone to enter the CIRTL Network learning community from a wide variety of disciplines, needs, and past experiences, and to achieve success as a teacher at a wide variety of engagement.
ASSOCIATE
CIRTL Associate — Describe and Recognize Value
Learning Objectives
see Associate certification requirements
Process
TEACHING-AS-RESEARCH
- Describe how to access the literature and existing knowledge about teaching and learning issues, in a discipline or more broadly.
- Define and recognize the value of the Teaching-as-Research process, and how it can be used for ongoing enhancement of learning.
- Describe a “full-inquiry” cycle.
- Describe how the integration of Evidence-Based Teaching, Learning Communities and Learning-through-Diversity within Teaching-as-Research can be integrated to implement and advance effective teaching practices for diverse learners.
Content
EVIDENCE-BASED TEACHING
- Describe and recognize the value of realistic well-defined, achievable, measurable and student-centered learning goals.
- Describe several known high-impact, evidence-based effective instructional practices and materials and recognize their alignment with particular types of learning goals.
- Describe several assessment techniques and recognize their alignment with particular types of learning goals.
LEARNING COMMUNITIES
- Describe and recognize the value of learning communities, and how they impact student learning.
- Describe several techniques for creating a LC within a learning environment, including strategies that promote positive interdependence between learners so as to accomplish learning goals.
- Describe several techniques and issues of establishing LCs comprising a diverse group of learners.
- Recognize the value of and participate in local professionally-focused learning communities associated with teaching and learning.
LEARNING THROUGH DIVERSITY
- Describe the scope of diversity in learning environments, of both students and instructor.*
- Describe the impact of diversity on student learning, in particular how diversity can enhance learning, and how inequities can negatively impact learning if not addressed.
- Describe how an instructor’s beliefs and biases can influence student learning.
- Describe and recognize the value of drawing on diversity in the development of teaching plans (including content, teaching practices and assessments) to foster learning.
- Describe several learning-through-diversity (LtD) techniques and strategies.
* Including, but not limited to, educational background, race, gender, ability, socioeconomic status, ethnicity, religion, sexual orientation, and cognitive skill.
PRACTITIONER
CIRTL Practitioner — Develop and Implement
Learning Objectives
see Practitioner certification requirements
Process
TEACHING-AS-RESEARCH
- Develop and execute a Teaching-as-Research plan for a limited teaching and learning project*
- Find and critically consider the literature and existing knowledge associated with the teaching and learning project.
- Create realistic well-defined, achievable, measurable and student-centered learning goals for the teaching and learning project.
- Find or develop assessment (measurement) tool(s) that are aligned with the learning goals of the teaching and learning project.
- Develop a teaching plan (a hypothesis) to accomplish learning goals.
- Implement the teaching plan and collect some data regarding achievement of learning goals.
- Analyze the data and draw evidence-based conclusions about the impact on student learning.
- Complete a full-inquiry cycle for the teaching and learning project by using findings to suggest improvements to the above actions.
- Show the integration of Evidence-Based Teaching, Learning Communities and Learning-through-Diversity to accomplish learning goals.
* Often this will be a first TAR effort, and need not be extensive or intended for public presentation. Optimally the project will be a coherent, complete experience of the full-inquiry cycle, but opportunities and situations vary from campus-to-campus and student-to-student.
Content
EVIDENCE-BASED TEACHING
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of existing evidence-based knowledge concerning high-impact, evidence-based teaching practices.
- Integrate one or more evidence-based teaching strategies into a teaching plan so as to accomplish learning goals.
- Implement one or more evidence-based teaching strategies for students in a learning experience.
LEARNING COMMUNITIES
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of the knowledge concerning LCs and their impact on student learning.
- Integrate one or more LC strategies into a teaching plan so as to accomplish learning goals and learning-through-diversity.
- Implement one or more LC strategies for students in a learning experience.
- Contribute to local professionally-focused learning communities associated with teaching and learning.
LEARNING THROUGH DIVERSITY
- Access the literature and existing knowledge to develop a deeper understanding of diversity and its impact on accomplishing learning goals.
- Examine and describe own beliefs and biases, including how they may influence their students’ learning.
- Determine the diverse backgrounds among a group of students, and consider the opportunities and challenges of the findings on each student’s learning.
- Create a teaching plan that incorporates content and teaching practices responsive to the students’ backgrounds.
- Integrate one or more LtD techniques and strategies in a teaching plan so as to use students’ diversity to enhance the learning of all.
- Implement one or more LtD strategies in a teaching experience.
SCHOLAR
CIRTL Scholar — Advance and Disseminate
Learning Objectives
see Scholar certification requirements
CIRTL Scholars have added to community knowledge about teaching and learning. They have designed and implemented a Teaching-as-Research investigation, and defended the findings to CIRTL learning-community peers. The significance of CIRTL Scholar Teaching-as-Research work is established through presentation and/or publication of the findings to all-university, regional, national, or international audiences.